Ransomware Threats in Healthcare Assignment Sample

Introduction To 7501CYQR Literature Review & Paper Critique

Task One: Critique of Research Papers

Article 1:

i. Summary of the paper

The primary article named “Physician Practise Cybersecurity Threats: Ransomware” actually inspects the expanding risks concerning ransomware in healthcare as the resilience of the sector on information technological advancements expands. Furthermore, this article actually emphasises healthcare suppliers' vulnerability to potential implications and cyber threats concerning compromised IT systems with an effective focus on threats of ransomware. Furthermore, the strategies are actually handed out to help healthcare suppliers respond, avoiding and identifying different types of threats at the time of understanding the actual role of IT in the delivery process of healthcare facilities.

Struggling with assignments? Get expert assistance now! How Does Online Assignment Help Service Work? It's simple—share your requirements, let our professionals craft a high-quality, plagiarism-free assignment, and receive it on time.

ii. Problem addressed and research challenges

In the article named “Physician Practise Cybersecurity Threats: Ransomware”, the understood difficulty is the expanding sophistication and damages caused by different types of ransomware attacks in the entire healthcare industry. In particular, the ultimate concern actually derives from the actual weaknesses in Information Technology procedures along with the resilience of the sector on proper technology. Moreover, this specific study acknowledges the healthcare suppliers who are vulnerable to cyber attacks as they depend on IT for different types of important tasks. For be specific, the study also addresses the actual possibility concerning different types of low-time effects and further discusses some of the specific dangers that healthcare personnel face when protecting crucial patient information.

iii. Main contribution of the paper

The ultimate contribution of the first article is to supply pathways for different types of healthcare professionals to efficiently confront the actual rising difficulty of ransomware. Furthermore, the respective study entirely focuses on the detection of ransomware, and prevention along with a huge response, further supplying different types of practical insights for healthcare suppliers to enhance their cybersecurity processes. In addition, the paper further raises awareness concerning critical requirements for different types of cybersecurity measures to safeguard the information of patients and maintain the actual integrity of healthcare operations by emphasising the healthcare sectors' vulnerabilities.

iv. Strong aspects of the paper

Different excellent parts concerning the first article actually contribute to the overall worth of the study. For beginning, the respective article actually represents a proper and recognisable definition concerning ransomware,detailing how it actually exploits flows in technological advancements and human behaviour respectively. Furthermore, this particular clarity actually helps in strengthening the entire study by making complicated topics of cybersecurity to a huge range concerning audiences, incorporating healthcare professionals with different levels concerning technical experiences. Besides that, the respective article also contextualises the actual ransomware evolution as a proper cybersecurity threat before the actual widespread utilisation of the internet with the help of detailing the initial ransomware incident that took place in 1989. Furthermore, the historical viewpoint actually enriches the entire story by illustrating the adaptability and presence concerning different types of ransomware threats.

Besides that, the respective article actually delves into different types of environments concerning ransomware attackers. For being specific, the respective study also adds a proper level of granularity to the actual knowledge concerning threat actors with the help of categorising them as proper state-sponsored enterprises, organised criminal gangs and individual hackers as well.

v. Weaknesses and suggestions for improvements

For the first article, there are some of the significant flaws in the article that, if resolved, could enhance its actual usefulness. For starters, utilising recent statistical information or case studies would further expand the actual relevance of the handed out techniques. For entirely reflecting the present surroundings of different types of ransomware threats, in the healthcare setting, updated information is entirely crucial. Moreover, the study also discusses different types of resolutions for lessening the actual risk concerning ransomware and might benefit from in-depth analysis or some of the real instances concerning effective implementation. Besides that, real-world instances or circumstances would further clarify some proper application concerning the proposed resolutions, further supplying a tangible guidance for different types of healthcare professionals for strengthening their actual cybersecurity measures.

Article 2:

i. Summary of the paper

The second article named “Ransomware Recovery and Imaging Operations: Lessons Learned and Planning Considerations” actually examines the aftermath concerning different types of ransomware attacks inside the management of healthcare services. For being specific, this article actually supplies different types of practical concepts that are actually gleaned from ransomware recovery in the real world. Besides that, the respective proposal concerning the recovery framework of the fourth phase, further labelling acute care of patients, recovery strategies, imaging operations and incident communication is taken into account as the major addition. In other words, the respective emphasis is on the actual effects concerning ransomware attacks on the workflows of patient care, further considering the necessity for a proper recovery strategy that includes both long-term and immediate ramifications.

Hence, with the help of the above discussion, it can be opined that both articles emphasise the seriousness concerning different types of ransomware attacks in healthcare settings, further underlying the actual ramifications for institutional and patient care processes. The actual integration concerning the findings of the articles actually informs a holistic recognition of attacks in healthcare, which further incorporates both effective recovery plans and proactive measures for emerging different types of cyber threats.

ii. Problem addressed and research challenges

The study titled “Ransomware Recovery and Imaging Operations: Lessons Learned and Planning Considerations” inspects the actual issues concerning ransomware attacks's repercussions in the workflow of healthcare management systems. Moreover, the key research challenge is ultimately to advance efficient recovery resolutions that can further resolve the actual damage caused by different types of ransomware events. Besides that, the report actually notes that some old-aged downtime procedures inside workplaces might not effectively address or label the actual scope concerning the interruption along with recovery timespans respectively.

Therefore, with the help of the above discussion, it can be mentioned that the main difficulty in both papers is the influence concerning ransomware on healthcare operations further ranges from lengthy downtime to impaired care for patients. The ultimate research concern is to advance resolutions that address immediate difficulties along with healing procedures and long-term repercussions. To be specific, these concerns underline the actual requirement for different types of healthcare organisations to strengthen individual cybersecurity actions and further construct recovery plans that sync with the expanding landscape concerning different types of cyber threats.

iii. Main contribution of the paper

The core contributions concerning the second article are actually generated from practical experiences and insights generated from the recovery experience of the real-world ransomware. For being specific, this article actually suggests a four-phased framework of recovery plans for patient care and imagining operations. Furthermore, this study also helps to the actual advancement of effective resolutions for lessening the actual influence concerning ransomware attacks on the workflows of healthcare with the help of sharing these experiences and in reflecting a total recovery approach respectively. In addition, the suggested framework actually hands out a nuanced and a systematic approach for helping healthcare employees to respond and prepare for multifaceted difficulties which are supplied by different types of ransomware insights.

Notwithstanding, both of the articles actually advances the recognition of different types of ransomware dangers in hospitality settings as well. The respective efforts collectively hand out to one specific holistic approach for labelling the dynamic surrounding concerning cyber threats in the entire healthcare industry.

iv. Strong aspects of the paper

Different types of practical insights are further being obtained from recovery experiences of the real-world and further stand out as a proper component in the second-most article. Furthermore, the paper actually reveals different types of lessons learned, further blistering its actual legitimacy with the help of basing recommendations in the situations from the real world. Besides that, this direct experience actually strengthens the entire study with the help of providing meaningful advice from healthcare employees who are facing similar difficulties. Notwithstanding, a major strength is taken into account as the respective proposal of a four phased recovery planning framework. Besides that, the structured strategy, which incorporates recovery measures, imaging operations, incident communication and patient care respectively. Besides that, the systematic and clarity of this approach actually strengthens the paper, further making it a fruitful tool for organisations looking to strengthen their actual resilience against some of the ransomware assaults.

Hence, it can be concluded that the success of both articles resides in their ability to clearly express complicated cybersecurity concepts, provide historical context, provide nuanced perspectives on criminals, share real-world knowledge, and suggest organised frameworks. In particular, these factors all lead to a thorough and insightful examination of ransomware risks in the medical field.

v. Weaknesses and suggestions for improvements

In the second-most article, more particular details or instances to demonstrate the suggested rehabilitation framework in operation are potential improvements. Real-world examples would strengthen the framework's credibility and provide a more realistic roadmap for healthcare organisations negotiating the complexity of recovery after a ransomware assault. Additionally, more details about the technology or tools used in the process of recovery would be beneficial to the article. In other words, offering knowledge about the precise tools or processes used during the recuperation experience would allow healthcare practitioners to try to apply comparable strategies with practical direction. While the ongoing readiness process is discussed, the paper may benefit from more information on how it will be carried out and maintained.

References

• Budke, C. and Enko, P. (2019). Physician Practice Cybersecurity Threats: Ransomware. [online] Available at: https://www.research-writing.com/MRP_projects_files/NAH/file_attech/physicianpracticecybersecuritythreats2531.pdf [Accessed 4 Nov. 2023].
• Chen, P.-H., Bodak, R. and Gandhi, N.S. (2021). Ransomware Recovery and Imaging Operations: Lessons Learned and Planning Considerations. Journal of Digital Imaging, 34(3). doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10278-021-00466-x.

Task Two: Survey Paper

Introduction

Ransomware attacks have emerged as an intimidating threat to data security with severe implications for various sectors but now their impact is more profound in the healthcare industry. Ransomware is malicious software that can lock users out of their computer system until a ransom is paid has a long and evolving history dating back to its first reported appearance as the aids Trojan in 1989. In recent years it has escalated from relatively primitive forms disrupted via floppy disks to more sophisticated strains that exploit vulnerabilities in the healthcare system. The healthcare industry crucial for the well-being of individual hospital clinics and pharmaceutical companies has seen a surge in ransomware incidents with attackers targeting electronically protected health information and demanding substantial ransom. The growth of the healthcare industry digital infrastructure has expanded the attack surface for cyber criminals making it an attractive target.

Get Extra 10% OFF on your WhatsApp order!

use my discount

The shift from simple locker ransomware to crypto-ransomware demands payment in cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. This has proven to be a profitable strategy for hackers as evidenced by the rapid spread and effectiveness of crypto locker in 2013 which extorted millions of dollars within a short period. Furthermore, it has been also found that in 2016 the Department of Justice reported an alarming increase in ransomware attacks where the United States alone was estimated to suffer huge losses. The healthcare sector is particularly susceptible as highlighted by “International Business Machine (IBM)” which detected disproportionately the number of cyber incidents within this industry. Therefore, the existing study underscores the urgency of addressing ransomware threats in healthcare and the necessity of comprehensive measures to protect critical patient data and ensure uninterrupted delivery of healthcare services. Through identifying the major research challenges and critique of adjusting work this study is going to create a proper understanding of the growing concern surrounding ransomware in the healthcare sector.

Major research challenges in the area

Addressing the persuasive and evolving threat of ransomware in the healthcare sector presents a complex landscape that consists of far-reaching implications This challenges encompass technical policy and strategic aspects that require comprehensive solutions. Ransomware strains are continually evolving, adapting to cyber security differences and becoming more sophisticated (Thamer and Alubady, 2021). Data security and privacy are the major challenges as protecting patient data is paramount in healthcare. Ransomware attacks compromise the confidentiality and integrity of “electronic health records (EHRs)” sensitive patient information (Dameff et al., 2023). Therefore the research needs more focus on enhancing data security measures to safeguard agents from such attacks. Innovation in encryption, secure storage, and access control are crucial areas of investigation to ensure present privacy. Another one is resilience and recovery because the healthcare system needs to maintain uninterrupted services for their patient care (Chen et al. 2021). Developing strategies to enhance system resilience and quick recovery from ransomware attacks is a significant research challenge. This includes studying effective backup systems, incident response plans and rapid restoration mechanisms. Therefore understanding the impact of downtime on patient care and designing a resilience system is critical.

Human factors and training are also a significant challenge because the human element remains a common entry point for a ransomware attack. Healthcare employees from key clinical to administration need effective training and awareness programs for recognizing and mitigating cyber threats (Triplett, 2022). Therefore the research needs to focus on the development of tailored training modules and best practices to ensure that staff can identify and respond to ransomware effectively to mitigate their risk. Another important challenge is regulatory compliance and cyber insurance which create a huge impact on healthcare organisations. The healthcare sector needs to navigate the complex regulatory framework and compile standards. Therefore this research needs to explore the alignment of cyber security practices with health-specific regulations such as the “Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)” (Budke and Enko, 2020). Additionally assessing the role of cyber insurance in mitigating financial losses and promoting better security practices are also vital. Threat intelligence and collaboration is vital because the healthcare sector can benefit from threat intelligence sharing and cross-sector collaboration. The research needs to delve into creating mechanisms for the timely sharing of ransomware threat intelligence potentially through secure information-sharing platforms. Collaboration between US healthcare organisation servers experts and law enforcement is essential to address this evolving threat effectively (Neprash et al., 2022; Slayton, 2018). Hence, these challenges underscored the critical need for a multidisciplinary approach involving hyper-security threats to healthcare practitioners, policymakers and technology professionals. By addressing these challenges this research can contribute to the development of a resilient, secure and patient-centred healthcare system that can withstand the growing hazard of ransomware attack. Therefore, it can be stated that addressing these challenges is critical for ensuring the well-being of patients and the integrity of the healthcare system.

Critique of existing work

The digital revolution is a significant reason behind increasing cyber attacks, and ransomware attacks in the healthcare industry that affect security measures of healthcare systems globally. Triplett (2022) stated that healthcare, and pharmaceutical companies are concerned with using digital technology for managing patients' information concerning smart medical equipment. In these aspects, cyber-attacks are significant issues faced by the healthcare sector due to the use of electronic media technology for managing medical; records that affect the security of patients' data. In the same way, Thamer and Alubady (2021), stated that the continuous expansion of digitalisation in the healthcare sector is a significant aspect that leads to increased cyber-attacks in documentation or data management processes. For instance, the hacking frequency in the healthcare sector increased 55% to 64% between 2015 to 2016 with 173 incidents of data violation and data breaches across 14 hospitals due to the treads on electronic medical services (Thamer and Alubady, 2021). The recent protocol against Ransom-attack in the healthcare business is the “Remote Desk Protocol” developed by Microsoft to manage unauthorised access and increase data security in the healthcare system as a technology-based solution. Simultaneously, as opined by Dameff et al. (2023), nearly 80 hospitals in the UK including the National Health Service have faced ransomware attack-related issues due to the digitalisation of the healthcare system in 2017.

Furthermore, in 2020, ransomware attacks in UK hospitals led to $67 million financial loss with breaches of personal information for 15,000 patients (Dameff et al. 2023). This cyber attack affects the data security and financial security for the UK hospital sector concerning significant threats in business developments with the application of digital technology. The regional medical service has observed that the operational distribution through online platforms and management data with digital technology leads to the ecosystem of healthcare sectors with increased ransomware-related issues. In the same way, as cited by Neprash et al. (2022), current trends of digitalization in healthcare sectors are responsible for increasing the possibility of ransomware day by day. Nearly 374 incidents of ransomware attacks have occurred in the US hospital industry that affected 42 million patients between 2016 to 2021 due to using electronic systems for managing medical records Neprash et al. (2022). The increase of ransomware attacks in the electric healthcare system led to affects annual marginal financial performance of hospitals. The increase of ransomware attacks in digitalisation is caused by breaches of the personal health information of patients that leads to increased cancellation of scheduling healthcare management by nearly 38% between 2020 to 2021 (Neprash et al. 2022). Thus, ransomware attacks play a vital role in affecting the frequency of sophistication disrupting the delivery of healthcare services and jeopardising information integrity effectively. On the other hand, Budke and Enko (2020), researched that the ransomware attack was caused by entering a virus through email that affects the conducting Email phishing campaign. For instance, 94% of ransomware attacks in the healthcare industry are caused by email through downloading required data and files that leads to hacking the email accounts of the victim (Budke and Enko, 2020). Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency suggested that updating software, adequate training for email users and following safe secure internet browsing are important for avoiding ransomware attacks. As cited by Chen et al. (2021), current technology assets in the radiology departments of healthcare sectors are associated with RIS, PACS, and dictation software that can be operated through internal network connection.

In these aspects, the use of RIS, PACS, and dictation software in radiology departments is responsible for affecting data security and the possibility of ransomware and cyber-attacks effectively. Furthermore, the use of Crypto-currency by healthcare organisations is responsible for increased ransomware attacks due to a wide range of hackers in Crypto locker. On the other hand, Slayton (2018) stated that the Ransom attack in the healthcare sector was caused by online payment that was faced by Hollywood Presbyterian Medical Centre. Crypto Locker is a useful tool for hackers to attract accounts and access financial data that affects security and creates financial loss for a healthcare organisation. In Dell, the hacker has accessed 200,000 to 250,000 computers and input the first virus for 100 days with the h application of Crypto lockers (Slayton, 2018). Moreover, 0.4% of Crypto lockers are used by hackers for ransomware and hacked nearly $30,000,000 bitcoins within 3 months with the occurrence of 1500 incidents in 2015 globally (Slayton, 2018). Thus, using crypto-currency and online payment systems can affect the financial security of the hospital industry concerning increased ransomware. Apart from that, it can be stated that digitalisation in healthcare sectors is a significant reason behind increased cyberattacks and ransomware attacks in the healthcare sector.

Conclusion

Based on the above study, it is concluded that ransomware is a significant issue that has been faced by the healthcare industry due to the use of electronic base medical reports concerning the application of smart equipment. The use of crypto-currency, Electronic medical reports and online transactions is responsible for affecting the security of patients and financial data in a healthcare organisation. The possibility of ransomware attack is increasing day by day that affecting patients with a reduction of hospital performance. Moreover, financial threats have been faced by the hospital industry due to the use of crypto-currency and online transaction systems. The radiology departments is required network connection for operating RIS, PACS, and dictation software that also responsible for affects security measure. Furthermore, email is another source that causes the possibility of phishing and ransomware track that affects the security measure. The integration of security measures is important for overcoming cyber attack issues in the healthcare industry with adequate data and financial management with digital technology. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency recommends maintaining several aspects such as following authentic cite, and managing download file from email with security concerns that can reduce the possibility of ransomware attacks effectively. “Remote Desk Protocol” developed by Microsoft is considered a significant solution for reducing the possibility of ransomware attacks during the use of internet connection, and email in the healthcare sector.

References

• Budke, C. and Enko, P. (2020). Physician Practice Cybersecurity Threats: Ransomware. [online] Available at: https://www.research-writing.com/MRP_projects_files/NAH/file_attech/physicianpracticecybersecuritythreats2531.pdf [Accessed 4 Nov. 2023].
• Chen, P.-H., Bodak, R. and Gandhi, N.S. (2021). Ransomware Recovery and Imaging Operations: Lessons Learned and Planning Considerations. Journal of Digital Imaging, [online] 34(3). doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10278-021-00466-x.
• Dameff, C., Tully, J., Chan, T.C., Castillo, E.M., Savage, S., Maysent, P., Hemmen, T.M., Clay, B.J. and Longhurst, C.A. (2023). Ransomware Attack Associated With Disruptions at Adjacent Emergency Departments in the US. JAMA network open, [online] 6(5), p.e2312270. doi:https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.12270
• Neprash, H.T., McGlave, C.C., Cross, D.A., Virnig, B.A., Puskarich, M.A., Huling, J.D., Rozenshtein, A.Z. and Nikpay, S.S. (2022). Trends in Ransomware Attacks on US Hospitals, Clinics, and Other Health Care Delivery Organizations, 2016-2021. JAMA Health Forum, 3(12), p.e224873. doi:https://doi.org/10.1001/jamahealthforum.2022.4873.
• Slayton, T.B. (2018). Ransomware: The Virus Attacking the Healthcare Industry. Journal of Legal Medicine, 38(2), pp.287–311. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/01947648.2018.1473186.
• Thamer, N. and Alubady, R. (2021). A Survey of Ransomware Attacks for Healthcare Systems: Risks, Challenges, Solutions and Opportunity of Research. 2021 1st Babylon International Conference on Information Technology and Science (BISCUITS). doi:https://doi.org/10.1109/bicits51482.2021.9509877.
• Triplett, W. (2022). Ransomware Attacks on the Healthcare Industry. Journal of Business, Technology and Leadership, 4(1), pp.1–13. doi:https://doi.org/10.54845/btljournal.v4i1.31.

Task Three: Essay about Legal, Social and Ethical issues

Introduction

In the modern healthcare scene, the actual integration concerning technological advancements has actually resulted in some unparalleled efficiencies and improvements. Notwithstanding, this online transition has actually not been without its hurdles, with the exploding threat concerning ransomware attacks as one of the prominent topics for discussion. Furthermore, this digital transition has not been devoid of its hurdles, with the increasing risk of ransomware attacks being one of the most significant worries. Be specific, Ransomware, a type of spyware that is aimed to steal data and demand money for its release, has progressively targeted healthcare organisations, posing a substantial risk to patient confidentiality, medical operations, and healthcare system integrity. This paper investigates the legal, interpersonal, and ethical components of attacks by ransomware in healthcare, focusing on the ramifications for individuals as well as the larger societal framework.

Thesis Statement: Ethical aspects of ransomware attacks in the healthcare sector raise concerns about patient privacy duty of care resource allocation and transparency in healthcare practices.

Discussion

Legal Aspects

Attacks by ransomware in hospitals not only disrupt operations but also provoke an intricate network of legal considerations, the majority of which are around client confidentiality and the security of data. In the United States, the “Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act” (HIPAA) serves as a foundation for regulatory frameworks protecting the confidentiality and security of patient information. Ransomware breaches, which jeopardise the security and confidentiality of proprietary health data, pose a serious barrier to HIPAA compliance. Furthermore, healthcare providers are required by HIPAA to employ strict protections that safeguard “Protected Health Information” (PHI) from unauthorised access, disclosure, and modification (Budke and Enko, 2020). In addition, with the help of definition, ransomware attacks impair these security measures, potentially resulting in unauthorised access to patient details. Following such assaults, institutions may face legal ramifications like regulatory fines, civil obligations, and reputational harm.

On the other hand, the legal ramifications go beyond HIPAA compliance, embracing a larger range of safeguarding information and breach reporting requirements. In the event of a data breach, some jurisdictions have established legislation requiring rapid and transparent communication. In the event of a ransomware attack, healthcare facilities may be required by law to alert both regulatory agencies and affected persons. Failure to comply with these reporting duties may result in extra-legal implications and a garnishment of the institution's reputation. In other words, there are legal issues to making payments of ransoms. While law enforcement frequently advises against accepting ransoms, some organisations may view it as an essential way to speed up data recovery. However, those payments may unwittingly violate laws against the sponsorship of illegal operations. The legal complexities concerning the payment of ransoms in the settings of health care providers are complex and present decision-makers with challenges.

Notwithstanding, legal structures have evolved in recent years to recognise the gravity of cyber dangers in healthcare. Legislation has been suggested to increase the penalties for harmful cyber actions directed at healthcare companies. This reflects an increasing recognition of the special issues presented by malware in the healthcare industry, as well as an effort to establish legal instruments to prevent and penalise perpetrators. Therefore, it can be mentioned that compliance with existing standards, particularly HIPAA, is critical for healthcare facilities seeking to maintain patient privacy while avoiding legal ramifications. As the cyber security landscape develops, ongoing legal changes will influence the framework under which healthcare organisations negotiate the complicated convergence of technology, information regarding patients, and the law.

Social Aspects

A ransomware attack is responsible for affecting the trust of patients in healthcare services and the use of electric medical services due to fear of data breaches and the leakage of personal information. The long-term psychological consequences arise due to facing cyberattacks and ransomware attacks related to issues by people that include post-traumatic stress, panic attacks and depression. In this aspect, a ransomware attack is responsible for affecting the reputation of the healthcare system due to affects performance through radaring files, and inaccessibility of critical information. Furthermore, the operational process can become slower and inoperable due to ransomware infection in electronic devices in healthcare organisations. As stated by Nifakos et al. (2021), staff in healthcare sectors and clinicals became worried due to the frequency of ransomware attacks and cyber-attacks as well as data vulnerabilities. As per the observation of the World Health of Health Organisation of Information and Communication, technology leads to an increased possibility of cyberattack that affects the trust and interest of people in digital health systems effectively.

Cyber-attack in the healthcare industry is responsible for hacking patients' personalities such as banking information, and social security numbers. As cited by Javaid et al. (2023), the life-critical service faced significant danger due to the increasing possibility of ransomware attacks in the healthcare system concerning the use of digital technology that makes the patients and staff in the hospital panic and worry. The trustworthiness of common people in the next-generation healthcare service is affected due to increased cyber attacks and ransom attacks in healthcare sectors. As cited by Thamer and Alubady (2021), the security mecate of healthcare services was affected due to ransomware that leads to affected more thyme 200 patients in 2016 through financial fraud. based on these aspects, ransomware attacks lead to affect trust and make them worried about the common people acquiring healthcare services effectively. Moreover, the reputation of the US healthcare sector has been affected due to an increase of 9% in ransomware attacks from 2015 to 2016 (Thamer and Alubady, 2021). Thus, the quality of healthcare services is affected due to the use of digital technology that is responsible for creating people's panic and warlord concerning social aspects.

Ethical Aspects

Ransomware attacks in the healthcare sector not only raise technical and security concerns but also evoke significant ethical dilemmas. As stated by Hofmann (2020), ethically the primary concern in ransomware attacks is the breach of patient privacy. Healthcare organisations have a fundamental responsibility to protect the confidentiality and integrity of patient data (Budke and Enko, 2020). Ransomware attacks violate this trust potentially exposing sensitive medical records and personal information to unauthorised individuals. Patients rely on the healthcare provider to safeguard their data and breaches erode this resistance. As per the statement of Supady et al., (2021), healthcare professionals have a moral duty of care to their patients. Ransomware attacks and disrupts the delivery of critical healthcare services that enhance patient well-being. This interruption may result in delayed treatment rescheduled surgeries and missed diagnoses. The healthcare provider fulfils the duty of care when they cannot access vital patient information due to ransomware. Furthermore, the principles of beneficence and non-maleficence are central to medical ethics (Varkey, 2021). Ransomware attacks introduce a conflict between this principle. Paying the ransom to recover data may be viewed as necessary for patient care aligning with beneficence. However, this action could also encourage cybercrime and fund further malicious activities which contradict non-maleficence.

Ethical dilemmas emerge regarding resource allocation where a healthcare organisation needs to allocate resources to address the ransomware incident potentially diverting funds from patient care and other essential services. It also focused on deciding how to balance these competing needs while upholding ethical principles that are a complex challenge. In addition, ethical healthcare practices emphasise transparency and open communication with patients (Varkey, 2021). In the aftermath of a ransomware attack, a healthcare provider needs to communicate the breach and its implications to affected patients. Balancing the ethical duty to inform patients with potential concerns about the breach's extent and its impact on patient ownership and trust (Chiruvella and Guddati, 2021). Ethical consideration extends to proactive measures where healthcare organisations need to have ethics to exercise due diligence in implementing robust cyber security measures to protect patient data. Furthermore, ethical responsibilities also extend to collaboration with law enforcement and other healthcare organisations. Reporting incidents and sharing threat intelligence is vital to address ransomware attacks. Therefore it can be stated that ransomware attacks in the healthcare sector present complex ethical challenges through its delicate balance between patient privacy trust and the ethical duties of healthcare providers.

Conclusion

Based on the above discussion it can be concluded that the legal implications of attacks by ransomware in healthcare highlight the critical necessity for robust cybersecurity safeguards. Compliance with existing standards, like HIPAA, is critical for protecting patient privacy and avoiding legal ramifications. In particular, the changing legal landscape recognises the gravity of cyber dangers in healthcare, indicating a concerted effort for prevention and punishing perpetrators. As healthcare institutions struggle with the complex issues posed by ransomware, continued legislative developments will play a critical role in determining the sector's resilience in the face of chronic and changing cyber threats.

On the other hand, collaboration between law and cybersecurity specialists is vital alongside regulatory compliance. Proactive actions, such as revising cybersecurity rules regularly and completing extensive risk assessments, can protect healthcare facilities from potential legal hazards. Furthermore, cultivating a culture of security education and awareness among healthcare professionals is critical. Legal structure alone cannot ensure resilience; a comprehensive solution that combines legal expertise with effective cybersecurity practices is required.

References

• Budke, C. and Enko, P. (2020). Physician Practice Cybersecurity Threats: Ransomware. [online] Available at: https://www.research-writing.com/MRP_projects_files/NAH/file_attech/physicianpracticecybersecuritythreats2531.pdf [Accessed 4 Nov. 2023].
• Chiruvella, V. and Guddati, A.K. (2021). Ethical Issues in Patient Data Ownership. Interactive Journal of Medical Research, 10(2), p.e22269. doi:https://doi.org/10.2196/22269.
• Hofmann, T. (2020). How organisations can ethically negotiate ransomware payments. Network Security, 2020(10), pp.13–17. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/s1353-4858(20)30118-5.
• Javaid, D.M., Haleem, Prof.A., Singh, D.R.P. and Suman, D.R. (2023). Towards insighting Cybersecurity for Healthcare domains: A comprehensive review of recent practices and trends. Cyber Security and Applications, 1, p.100016. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.csa.2023.100016.
• Nifakos, S., Chandramouli, K., Nikolaou, C.K., Papachristou, P., Koch, S., Panaousis, E. and Bonacina, S. (2021). Influence of Human Factors on Cyber Security within Healthcare Organisations: A Systematic Review. Sensors, 21(15), p.5119. doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/s21155119.
• Supady, A., Curtis, J.R., Brown, C.E., Duerschmied, D., von Zepelin, L.A., Moss, M. and Brodie, D. (2021). Ethical obligations for supporting healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic. European Respiratory Journal, 57(2), p.2100124. doi:https://doi.org/10.1183/13993003.00124-2021.
• Thamer, N. and Alubady, R. (2021). A Survey of Ransomware Attacks for Healthcare Systems: Risks, Challenges, Solutions and Opportunity of Research. 2021 1st Babylon International Conference on Information Technology and Science (BICITS). doi:https://doi.org/10.1109/bicits51482.2021.9509877.
• Varkey, B. (2021). Principles of clinical ethics and their application to practice. Medical Principles and Practice, [online] 30(1), pp.17–28. doi:https://doi.org/10.1159/000509119.