Author, Year, reference
|
Short title
|
Discipline
|
Research Aims Research Questions
|
Conceptual framework/ Theories utilized
|
Method
|
Context / sample
|
Key findings
|
Gaps in the literature/ shortcoming of the paper
|
Al Khajeh, E. H. (2018)
|
Impact of leadership styles on organizational performance.
|
Journal of Human Resources Management Research
|
To explore Association among organisational performance and leadership approach
|
Analysis of management and leadership in terms of failure and success
|
Primary and secondary approach with quantitative style; survey instrument and survey questionnaire.
|
20 randomly selected organisations
|
There is negative relationship of bureaucratic, transactional and charismatic leadership with organisational performance
|
Use of quantitative data only; reduced scope and applicability
|
Pancasila, I., Haryono, S., & Sulistyo, B. A. (2020)
|
Effects of work motivation and leadership toward work satisfaction and employee performance: Evidence from Indonesia.
|
The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business
|
To determine the impact of appropriate leadership and work motivation on performance and job satisfaction of employees
|
Analysis of structural qualities within organisations
|
Primary research random sampling approach and collected proportional demography
|
355 samples of Bukit Asam, coal mining company, Indonesia
|
There is direct impact of leadership approaches on the job satisfaction, employee performance and business success
|
Lack of specific analysis and particular evaluation
|
Guterresa, L.F.D.C., Armanu, A. & Rofiaty, R. (2020)
|
The role of work motivation as a mediator on the influence of education-training and leadership style on employee performance.
|
Management Science Letters
|
To identify the impact of leadership style and education and training in work motivation
|
The utilisation of education training programme to improve employee performance and motivation
|
Questionnaire survey with 86 employees as sample
|
Ministry of Education, Indonesia
|
The work motivation has mediating influence on employee performance through leadership style but not on education training
|
Lack of practicability of work motivation strategies in education training process
|
Schwarz, G., Eva, N. & Newman, A. (2020)
|
Can public leadership increase public service motivation and job performance?
|
Public Administration Review
|
To increase the understanding of significance in public sector associated with the performance and other employee aspects
|
Social learning theory to stimulate the impacts of leadership within public sector
|
Implementing multilevel modelling network among 300 civil servants and 64 managers
|
Civil servants within China
|
Strong and positive relationship among job performance and PSM with network governance leadership
|
Lack of casual conclusions and no control on common variances
|
Paais, M. & Pattiruhu, J.R. (2020)
|
Effect of motivation, leadership, and organizational culture on satisfaction and employee performance.
|
The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics, and Business
|
To investigate the impact of organisational culture leadership and motivation on employee performance and satisfaction
|
Focus on HRM approaches in academic research with critical review
|
Survey of 155 employees by proportionate stratified random sampling
|
Employees of Bahana resources Limited North Sairam district Central maluku Regency Indonesia
|
The job satisfaction is highly influenced by leadership and motivation
|
Limited data collection regarding industry and over all development
|
Ibarra, H., & Scoular, A. (2019)
|
The leader as coach.
|
Harvard Business Review
|
Explorer empirical evidences regarding a leadership competence and motivation among employees
|
Implementing explanatory casualty approach to focus on motivation and performance in education
|
Data collection by using service as One-Shot study
|
250 respondents from 7 district Indonesia East Java Province
|
The work motivation impacts performance and competence
|
Negative impacts of Limited capitalisation within campus
|
Matsuo, M. (2018)
|
How does managerial coaching affect individual learning?
|
Personnel review
|
To demonstrate the importance of coaching and guidance while managing people at workplace
|
Analysis of managerial model for improving guidance at workplace
|
Secondary method of research with descriptive analysis
|
Employees, United States
|
The different managerial model has positive impact on managing employees as a coaching and providing guidance
|
Lack of practicality and Limited area of exploration
|
Rahardja, U., Moein, A. and Lutfiani, N. (2018)
|
Leadership, competency, working motivation and performance of high private education lecturer with institution accreditation B: Area kopertis IV Banten province.
|
Man India
|
To identify and evaluate the role of managerial linking and team reflexivity in individual learning and coaching
|
Evaluation of impacts of guidance and mentorship on employees
|
Survey of 98 engineering team within electronic and automobile industry
|
Automobile and electronic engineers, Japan
|
The managerial coaching has a direct impact on the individual and team learning
|
Impact on engineering traits due to interdependency within teams
|